When showing the whole class our ideas for our magazine advert they gave us some really good feedback . We knew that by asking the class what they liked about the advert and what they didn't like that we would get some good feedback in order to make a great advert that matches the conventions of the genre .
The class did not like our first idea very much as they did not like the how the boarder was placed at the top and they did not like the picture that we used . They liked that we kept with the themes that were on the digipak but they did not like how it was set out .
They liked the first design and the second design equally, they liked how the boarder looked and they liked how simplistic the design is . They also liked the picture that we used as it kept with the brand identity . They both liked the designs equally so it was up to us to decide how we wanted to set it out .
Similarly they liked the look of the third design as it was very similar to the second design . Some people said they liked the thickness of the second design boarder more and some said they liked the third more . Because they were both so equally voted for we decided to pick qualities that we liked as a group to put on the magazine advert .